LissafiKafin bugawaNazariyyaKaratun minti 4

ƘALUBALEN BORSUK A 4D: AMSAR BIYAR CE KO SHIDA

Tambayar Borsuk tana da sauƙin faɗi. A ɗauki wata siffa mai iyaka (bounded) sannan a auna diamita ɗinta: tazara mafi faɗi tsakanin kowane maki biyu nata. Sannan a yanka siffar zuwa guntaye, kowanne ya fi wannan diamita ƙunci tsantsa. Guntaye nawa ne za su isa a kowane hali?

A 1933, tambayar Borsuk ita ce ko, a girma n, guntaye n + 1 koyaushe sun isa. Ƙasa da haka ba zai yi aiki ba: a cikin alwatika mai daidaitattun gefe (equilateral triangle) mai gefen ɗaya, kowane kusurwoyi biyu suna da tazarar diamita ɗaya daidai, don haka kowace kusurwa tana buƙatar guntunta na kanta. Simplex mai daidaito (regular simplex) — sigar alwatika a girma n — ita ma tana buƙatar guntaye n + 1 don kusurwoyinta. Mafi ƙarancin adadin da ke aiki ga kowace siffa ana kiransa lambar Borsuk (Borsuk number), b_n.

An warware har zuwa girma uku

Hujjar Borsuk ta nuna cewa b₂ = 3: a cikin fili, guntaye uku koyaushe sun isa. A sarari, sanarwar b₃ = 4 ta zo daga Perkal a 1947, hujjar kuma daga Eggleston a 1955. Amma a 1993, Kahn da Kalai sun tabbatar da cewa hasashen ba daidai ba ne a girma masu yawa sosai.

Wannan ya bar wani giɓi mara daɗi. Girma huɗu yanzu shi ne mafi ƙanƙantar hali da har yanzu ba a amsa ba.

Iyakar da ke ci gaba da faɗuwa

Ga girma huɗu, amsar aƙalla biyar ce (kusurwoyin simplex mai girma huɗu). Tambayar ita ce guntaye nawa ne za su isa. Iyakar Lassak ta 1982, b_n ≤ 2^(n−1) + 1, ta ba da tara. Tolmachev da Voronov sun saukar da ita zuwa takwas a watan Mayu 2026. A watan Oktoba 2026, Arman, Bondarenko, Prymak da Radchenko sun rufe kowace siffa mai girma huɗu mai diamita ɗaya da ƙwallaye bakwai, kowanne da diamita ƙasa da 0.9999: bakwai.

Yanzu aikin Logan Chalmers, a University of Otago a New Zealand, ya tabbatar da cewa guntaye shida koyaushe sun isa. Don haka lambar Borsuk ta girma huɗu biyar ce ko shida.

Guntaye ba dole su zama ƙwallaye ba

Muhimmin lura ya dace a layi ɗaya: guntun da ya fi ɗaya ƙunci ba dole ne ya shiga cikin ƙwallo da ya fi ɗaya ƙunci ba. Hujjar da ta gabata ta yi amfani da ƙwallaye kawai. Wannan hujjar tana barin guntun ƙarshe ya ɗauki kowace siffa.

Hujjar ta fara da kewaye siffar a cikin mafi matsatsin ƙwallo mai yiwuwa, sannan ta jera siffofi bisa girman wannan ƙwallo.

  • Siffofi masu faɗi (babban ƙwallon kewaye): ƙwallaye biyar, kowanne da radius 9999/20000 — wato diamita 0.9999 — ana sanya su kusa da makin da siffar ke taɓa ƙwallon da ke kewaye da ita, an ja su zuwa tsakiya. Duk abin da ƙwallaye biyar ɗin suka kasa kamawa ya zama guntu na shida guda ɗaya. Hujjar ta nuna cewa wannan saura ba zai taɓa ɗauke da maki biyu masu tazarar ɗaya daidai ba, don haka shi ma ya fi dukan siffar ƙunci. Inda gini na baya ya buƙaci ƙarin ƙwallaye biyu, guntu ɗaya da ya rage ya isa.
  • Siffofi masu dunƙulewa (ƙaramin ƙwallon kewaye): ana yanka dukan ƙwallon zuwa mazugi (cones) shida iri ɗaya daga tsakiyarsa, waɗanda aka gina daga rukunin kwatance uku-uku masu daidaito (equilateral triples of directions) guda biyu da ke kwance a fili biyu masu tsaye a kan juna (perpendicular).
  • Duk abin da ke tsakani: a nan kwamfuta ce ke karɓar aiki. An raba yanayin (configurations) masu yiwuwa zuwa ƙananan akwatuna. A kan 1,512 daga cikinsu, ayyuka (functions) masu layi (linear) shida suna rarraba makin; sauran akwatunan an nuna cewa suna bayyana yanayin da ba zai iya faruwa ba. A cikin kowane guntu, faɗin yana da iyaka ta faɗin wani polytope mai coordinates masu rabo (polytope with rational coordinates). Kowane guntu yana fitowa ya fi ɗaya ƙunci da tazara da aka tabbatar: murabba’in diamitarsa bai wuce 1 − 86 × 10⁻¹⁰ ba.

An duba ta da na’ura

Hujjar da aka gina a kan akwatuna 1,512 na ɓangarori (fractions) tsantsa tana da wuyar dubawa da hannu. An tsara theorem ɗin a harshen Lean: wannan shiri ya duba dukkan hujjar, tare da laburaren lissafinsa; bayanan da tsarin Lean (formalisation) a buɗe suke ga jama’a. Shirye-shiryen Python ne suka gina rabe-raben suka kuma lissafa iyakokin. A cikin wata “sanarwar AI” (AI declaration), takardar ta bayyana cewa OpenAI’s Astra ta taimaka wajen binciken hujjoji, shirya tsarin Lean da kuma shirya takardar, kuma ta ce Chalmers ne ke ɗaukar cikakken alhakinta.

Biyar ko shida?

Takardar ba ta warware tambayar ba, kuma ta faɗi abin da amsar za ta nufi. Idan ainihin adadin shida ne, girma huɗu shi ne mafi ƙanƙantar girma da hasashen Borsuk ke kasawa a cikinsa.

Ta ƙare da wata tambaya mafi kaifi. Shin wata siffa mai diamita ɗaya, da ke kwance a kan saman ƙwallo (sphere) mai radius da bai wuce 1/√2 ba a girma huɗu, za ta iya buƙatar guntaye shida? Idan irin wannan siffa ta wanzu, wani sanannen gini zai tura kasawar zuwa kowane girma da ke sama. Girma ɗaya, biyu da uku za su kasance su kaɗai ne daidai inda guntaye n + 1 koyaushe suka isa.