SIFFAR DA TA FI MUNIN CUNKUSHEWA: SIFFA MAI KUSURWA TAKWAS DA AKA ZAGAYE KUSURWOWINTA?
Ɗauki wata shimfiɗaɗɗiyar siffa — mai kumburi waje (convex), kuma mai daidaito a kewayen tsakiyarta (symmetric about its centre), kamar tsabar kuɗi ko faranti mai zagayayyun gefuna. A jera kwafinta iri ɗaya a kan tsari na yau da kullum (regular grid), kowane kwafi yana nisa da na gaba ta matakai iri ɗaya, ba tare da wani ya hau kan wani ba, kuma a tura su su matse juna gwargwadon iko. Wani ɓangare na fili koyaushe yana nan a buɗe. Mafi kyawun yawan cunkushewa (packing density) da siffa za ta iya kaiwa ta wannan hanya ya dogara da siffar; miƙa ta ko karkatar da ita (stretching or shearing) ba ya sauya shi.
Matsalar Reinhardt tana tambayar wace siffa ce ke da mafi kyawun yawan cunkushewa mafi ƙanƙanta: siffar da ta fi munin cunkushewa, ko da an jera ta da kyau gwargwadon iko.
Ɗan takara mai ban mamaki
A 1934, amsar da aka samu daga Reinhardt ita ce siffa mai kusurwa takwas daidai da aka sassauta (smoothed regular octagon), wato siffa mai kusurwa takwas daidai (regular octagon) wadda aka zagaye kusurwowinta da baka-bakan hyperbola. Kamar yadda sabuwar takardar preprint ta lura, matsalar ba kamar sauran tambayoyin cunkushewa ba ce: siffar da ta yi rashin nasara ba siffa mai madaidaitan gefuna (polygon) ba ce, kuma ba ellipse ba ce.
Ci gaba ya zo mataki-mataki. A 1947, aikin Mahler ya raba matsalar gida biyu: shin siffar da ta fi muni koyaushe “siffa mai madaidaitan gefuna da aka sassauta” (smoothed polygon) ce, wadda aka yi da adadin guda madaidaita da na hyperbola mai iyaka? Kuma idan haka ne, dole ne ta zama siffa mai kusurwa takwas ta Reinhardt? A 1986, aikin Nazarov ya nuna cewa siffa mai kusurwa takwas ɗin aƙalla mafi ƙanƙanta ce ta gida (local minimum): ɗan sauya siffarta kaɗan ba zai sa ta fi munin cunkushewa ba. Daga baya, aikin Hales ya sake fasalta tambayar a matsayin matsalar sarrafawa mafi kyau (optimal-control problem), inda ake zana kowane baka na iyakar siffar da sarrafawa mai tsayayye (constant control), kuma Hales da Vajjha sun tabbatar da tambayar farko ta Mahler — amma ba tare da adadin guda nawa siffar da ta fi muni za ta iya samu ba.
Hujjar da ake iƙirari
A cikin wata takardar preprint mai shafi 472 mai kwanan wata 17 ga Nuwamba 2026, Fei Xue na iƙirarin warware tambaya ta biyu. Babban theorem ɗin takardar ya bayyana cewa duk irin wannan siffa tana da mafi kyawun yawan cunkushewa da bai gaza
(8 − 4√2 − log 2) / (2√2 − 1),
ƙimar da siffa mai kusurwa takwas da aka sassauta ke kaiwa, kuma daidaito yana samuwa ne kawai ga siffa mai kusurwa takwas ɗin da kwafinta da aka miƙa ko aka karkata.
Gabatarwar takardar ta shimfiɗa tsarin aikin. Da farko, wata ƙayyadaddiyar iyaka kan adadin baka-baka, mai girman da ya fi gaban misali: ƙasa da 2¹⁶⁵. Sannan ƙiyasai masu kaifi sun saukar da ita zuwa 21 a mafi yawa. Hakan ya bar tsare-tsaren baka-baka 1,355 masu yiwuwa (“kalmomi”); lissafi na daidai ya kawar da 1,334 daga cikinsu, ya bar 21. Ƙarin nazarin siffofi (geometry) ya taƙaita waɗannan zuwa nau’o’i shida, masu suna R01 zuwa R06. Sannan takardar preprint ɗin tana kawar da kowanne da nasa ma’aunan lissafi (equations), ragewar geometry da lissafin da kwamfuta ta tantance, kuma ta kammala da cewa siffa mai kusurwa takwas kaɗai ce ta rage. Wani rataye (appendix) yana bayyana algorithms na tantancewa, kuma bayanan suna tare da takardar.
Wa ya yi me
Sashen godiya (acknowledgements) yana da gaskiya fiye da yadda aka saba. Hujjar da ta ba da iyaka ta farko mai ƙayyadadden adadi kan baka-bakan shawara ce ta Fei Xue. “ChatGPT dot”, a cewar rubutun, shi ne ya gudanar da dogon binciken ƙiyasin farashi (cost estimates), kuma “ChatGPT 6.1 Sol ne ya aiwatar da hujjojin nau’o’i shida da suka rage R01–R06 da kuma tsara rubutun”. Alhakin iƙirarin lissafi ya rage a kan Fei Xue.
Rubutun Fei Xue ya ba da labarin haɗuwa da matsalar a tattaunawar taron ƙara wa juna sani (seminar) tare da Chuanming Zong da Thomas Hales a kusan 2015, da kuma yadda matsalar ta ci gaba da hana Fei Xue natsuwa fiye da shekaru goma.
Abin da zai biyo baya
A yanzu, wannan hujja ce da aka sanar, wadda mutum ɗaya ya rubuta, a tsawon da masu karatu kaɗan ne za su iya karanta ta da sauri: wasu masana lissafi ba su tantance takardar preprint ɗin ba tukuna. Takardar ma ba ta ɓoye hakan ba, tana rufe gabatarwarta da fatan cewa “ƙarin aiki zai kai ga hujja mafi gajarta kuma mafi kyau”.
