Space & astronomy · the experiment
Follow the deuterium trail
A cold giant, a heavy methane, ices from the cold. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on what the deuterium of ε Ind Ab says about its birth.
1 · Compare the planets
Beginner
What did the JWST measure in the atmosphere of ε Ind Ab?
2 · Correct the methane
Methane gives (D/H)CH₄ = 5.4 × 10⁻⁵. The correction factor f = (D/H)CH₄ / (D/H)H₂ lies between 1.10 and 1.35.
Intermediate
What range do you get for the D/H of hydrogen, that of the whole planet?
3 · Rule out the cloud
Hypothesis: the cloud in which the ε Ind system was born was simply richer in deuterium than the Solar System's.
Expert
Why does the team rule out this explanation?
4 · Build the planet from our comets
Solar System comets have a D/H of about 3 × 10⁻⁴ in their water. Each comet swallowed also brings carbon and oxygen.
Expert
If ε Ind Ab had reached its D/H with such comets, what would its carbon and oxygen be?
Trail followed
—