Mathematics · the experiment
Punch holes in the ball
A plate that buckles, two critical loads, a conjecture from 1999 and a ring of tiny holes. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on how a ball with holes beat the perfect ball.
1 · The result2 · The square3 · First order4 · The limits
1 · State the result
Beginner
What do the three mathematicians show?
2 · Compare the square
For the buckling plate, numerical computations give a ratio of about 1.76 for the square, against about 1.7964 for the disc.
Intermediate
By roughly what percentage is the square below the disc?
3 · Explain the hidden gain
Expert
Why does the first-order calculation not reveal that the conjecture fails?
4 · Draw the limits
Expert
Does this result disprove the conjecture for convex shapes without holes?
Ball punched
—