Chemistry · the experiment
Make ice appear
A cold plasma, a little water, ions of both signs. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on how ice can form without any dust.
1 · Find what starts the ice
Beginner
In the Caltech plasma, what serves as the seed for the ice grains?
2 · Measure a cluster
The authors relate a grain's radius to its number of water molecules n: r = 2 × 10⁻¹⁰ n^(1/3) metres. A grain of 1,000 molecules has a radius of 2 nm.
Intermediate
What is the radius of a grain of 8,000 molecules?
3 · Remove the walls
In the laboratory, the plasma's electric field pushes positive clusters out to the walls. In the open sky or in a disk around a young star, there are no walls.
Expert
Which clusters keep the advantage there?
4 · Change the hydroxide
In a disk where planets form, the authors estimate that, at equal abundance, hydroxide ions would beat dust by about 2 × 10⁵. With 1 hydroxide for 100 water molecules, the advantage becomes about 2,000.
Expert
Where hydroxide is ten times rarer, 1 for 1,000 water molecules, what is the advantage?
Ice formed
—