Mathematics · the experiment
Unmask the fake link
Two random walks built from independent steps, a measure meant to catch any dependence, and a test that keeps crying wolf. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on nonsense correlations.
1 · Follow the correlation
Beginner
Two random walks are built from completely independent steps. What does their distance correlation do as the walks get longer?
2 · Turn a count into a share
At 5,000 steps, 1,644 of the 2,000 simulated pairs of independent walks have a distance correlation above 0.3.
Intermediate
What share of the pairs is that?
3 · Shuffle and test
To test independence, you shuffle the time order of one walk many times and check whether the real distance correlation stands out, at the 5% level.
Expert
For long independent walks, how often does this test wrongly declare a link?
4 · Weigh a tempting shortcut
In this model, taking the differences between successive values of each walk gives back its independent steps. Tests on the steps behave normally.
Expert
Does testing the steps settle whether the walks are independent?
Link unmasked
—