Space & astronomy · the experiment
Lay the planets flat
Sixteen systems, ours included, 32 planets, distant belts of dust and debris, and two rebels tilted by more than 40 degrees. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on how flat planetary systems are.
1 · Find where most planets orbit
Beginner
How do most of the 32 planets orbit compared with their system's debris belt?
2 · Turn a count into a share
With a strict 1-degree threshold, 26 planets out of 32, and 11 systems out of 16, still count as aligned.
Intermediate
What share of the planets passes the strict test?
3 · Read the measured angle
The angle measured for each planet is the difference between how its orbit and the disk are tilted, as seen from Earth.
Expert
What does that difference say about the true angle between the two planes?
4 · Test the birth hypothesis
The systems range from tens of millions to a few billion years old. The only two misaligned ones are among the oldest.
Expert
If tilts were mostly inherited at birth, from warped disks, what would the authors expect to see?
Planets laid flat
—