ALGORITHM NE KE ZAƁAR INDA ƳAN GUDUN HIJIRA ZA SU FARA
Ƴan gudun hijira sukan sha wahala wajen samun aiki a ƙasar da ta karɓe su. A ƙasashen Turai ashirin, takardar ta lura, yiwuwar samun aikinsu ta yi ƙasa da kusan kashi 12% fiye da ta baƙin haure masu kama da su, gibin da ke ɗaukar shekaru goma zuwa goma sha biyar. Watannin farko da shekarun farko bayan isowa su ne mafi muhimmanci, haka kuma inda aka sanya ɗan gudun hijira. Duk da haka a ƙasashe da yawa, ciki har da Switzerland, sanyawa tana bin kason gudanarwa, jami’ai kuma ba su da bayanai sosai kan inda kowane mutum zai fi samun nasara.
Shawara, ba yanke shawara ba
A 2018, Kirk Bansak, Jens Hainmueller da abokan aikinsu sun gabatar da haɗa ƴan gudun hijira ta algorithm (algorithmic refugee matching). Wani samfurin koyon na’ura, wanda aka horar a kan masu isowa na baya, yana hasashen yiwuwar kowane ɗan gudun hijira ya sami aiki a kowane wuri mai yiwuwa. Sannan wani mataki na inganta (optimisation) yana ba da shawarar sanyawa da ke ƙara yawan aikin yi da ake tsammani yayin da ake mutunta dukan kason. Wani jami’i ɗan Adam yana riƙe da yanke shawarar ƙarshe.
Har zuwa yanzu, an ƙiyasta amfanin ne kawai ta hanyar sake kunna bayanan baya. Wannan nazari, wanda Bansak (Jami’ar California, Berkeley), Hainmueller (Jami’ar Stanford) da Dominik Hangartner (ETH Zurich) suka jagoranta, ya ba da rahoton abin da marubutan suka yi imani shi ne gwaji na farko mai sarrafawa da aka raba bazuwa (randomised controlled trial) na wannan hanya, wanda aka gudanar tare da Sakatariyar Jiha ta Hijira ta Switzerland (SEM), ta amfani da wani farkon nau’in kayan aikinsu, GeoMatch.
Caca makauniya a cikin gudanarwa ta gaske
Daga Janairu 2020 zuwa Yuni 2023, kowane lamari da ya cancanta — iyali ko babba ɗaya da ya sami matsayin ɗan gudun hijira ko kariya ta wucin gadi, kuma wanda za a iya sanya shi a kowane canton — kwamfuta ta sanya shi cikin ɗaya daga cikin rukuni biyu, 50/50:
- algorithm: canton da GeoMatch ya yi hasashen zai ƙara yawan aikin yi;
- kwatanci (control): canton da aka zaɓa bazuwa daga cikin guraben da ke akwai, kamar a hanyar da aka saba.
Jami’an sanyawa sun ga allo ɗaya a kowane hali, kuma su ko ƴan gudun hijira ba su san a wane rukuni lamari yake ba. Kowane rukuni yana da kwafinsa iri ɗaya na kason bisa canton da bisa ƙasa. Wannan ƙira ta hana wata dabara mai sauƙi: algorithm ba zai iya tura ƙarin mutane zuwa cantons masu kasuwannin aiki masu ƙarfi ba. Zai iya inganta dacewa tsakanin mutum da wuri kawai.
Samfurin ya san kaɗan sosai: jinsi, shekaru, matsayin aure, girman iyali, ranar isowa, ƙasa da harshen uwa. Ilimi, tarihin aiki da ƙwarewar harshe ba a rubuta su a cikin rajistar da ya yi amfani da ita ba. Jami’ai sun bi shawarar da aka nuna kusan kashi 97% na lokaci.
Samfurin ƙarshe: lamurra 2,000, manya 2,156, mafi yawa daga Afghanistan (kashi 54%), Turkiyya (kashi 26%) da Siriya (kashi 9%).
Sakamakon
Babban sakamakon, wanda aka ƙayyade a cikin wani shiri da aka yi rajista a gaba, shi ne kason watannin da aka yi aiki a cikin shekaru uku na farko. A rukunin kwatanci, manya sun yi aiki a matsakaici kashi 22.3% na waɗannan watanni.
- Dukan rukunin shekaru (2020–2023): +maki 2.2 na kashi ga rukunin algorithm, kusan kashi 10% fiye, da tazarar amincewa (confidence interval) daga +0.05 zuwa +maki 4.3.
- Rukunin bayan Covid (2022–2023): +maki 3.9, kusan kashi 17% fiye. Gwajin ya fara makonni kafin annobar, kuma an horar da samfurin a kan bayanan kafin annoba; tasirin bai bambanta da sifili ba ga rukunin 2020 da 2021. Waɗannan kwatancen bisa rukuni ba a yi musu rajista a gaba ba.
- Yana ƙaruwa da lokaci: watanni 36 bayan sanyawa, kason iyalan da ke da aƙalla babba ɗaya a aiki ya fi da maki 5.2 (kusan kashi 11%).
- Ayyuka masu ƙarfi: aikin da ya ɗauki aƙalla watanni shida, +maki 5.6; kwangila mara ƙarshe a shekaru uku, +maki 4.5.
Mai araha, bisa ƙira
Ta ƙidaya kuɗin gwamnati kawai — tallafin da ba a sake biya, tare da gudummawa da haraji — marubutan sun ƙiyasta kowane ƙarin watan aiki da kusan franc ɗin Swiss 1,950. Da kuɗin gudanarwa da aka zata na franc 50 ga kowane babba, sun ƙiyasta kusan franc 1,300 na ribar tsabta ga kowane babba, rabo na kusan 27 zuwa 1. Sun kwatanta tasirin a shekaru uku da na shirye-shiryen da ke ƙara ɗaruruwan awanni na horon harshe, yayin da suke jaddada cewa algorithm ba madadin irin waɗannan darussa ba ne.
Suna kiran gwajin gwaji mai taka-tsantsan: farkon nau’in kayan aikin da aka daskarar, ƴan masu hasashe kaɗan, taswira mara zurfi, kaso masu tsauri, kuma rabin lamurran ne kawai ke akwai don ingantawa. Ko sababbin nau’o’i marasa ƙuntatawa za su fi kyau ya rage a gwada.
Wa ya gina shi, wa ya gwada shi
Marubutan ne suka samar da hanyar GeoMatch da kansu. Sun bayyana cewa ba su da rikicin muradu kuma sun ce ba su karɓi wani kuɗi daga gwamnatin Switzerland don samarwa ko gudanar da kayan aikin ba; Jami’ar Stanford, gidauniyoyi da ƙungiyoyin agaji ciki har da Google.org, da wani tallafin bincike na Turai ne suka ɗauki nauyin aikin. Bayan ƴan gudun hijira, suna ganin gwajin a matsayin shaida ta fili da ba safai ake samu ba cewa kayan aikin hasashe na iya inganta muhimman shawarwarin gwamnati idan suka taimaka, maimakon su maye gurbin, mutanen da ke yanke su — kuma a matsayin tunatarwa cewa dole a sake horar da irin waɗannan kayan aiki idan duniya ta canza, kamar yadda ta yi a 2020.
