Life sciences · the experiment
Find the birds' north again
A magnetic compass in the eye, radio waves far weaker than the Earth's field, a theory that gets the frequencies right and the strength wrong. Four questions, from beginner to expert, on a puzzle of bird navigation.
1 · Name what scrambles the compass
Beginner
In the experiments reviewed, what stops caged migratory songbirds from using their magnetic compass?
2 · Predict which band works
For the radical pair of cryptochrome, the theory sets a ceiling at about 116 megahertz: above it, radio waves find no internal rhythm to disturb. Blackcaps are exposed to two bands of radio noise of similar strength, one centred on 80 megahertz, the other on 140.
Intermediate
Which band should disorient them?
3 · Compute the time needed
Rule from the supplement: a magnetic field B noticeably affects the radical pair if B × τ ≥ 20, with B in microtesla and τ, the time the spins stay in step, in microseconds. A radio field of 1 nanotesla is 0.001 microtesla.
Expert
How long would the spins have to stay in step for this radio field to matter?
4 · Read the outcome of a proposed test
Imagine Hore's proposed test is done: after the isotope swap, theory predicts a ceiling of about 150 megahertz instead of 116, and blackcaps are now disoriented by the band at 140 megahertz too.
Expert
Which explanation does this result favour?
North found again
—