YAUSHE YA KAMATA VAR YA SOKE HUKUNCIN ALƘALIN WASA?
A ranar 26 ga Yuni 2026, a zagaye na ƙarshe na matakin rukuni na Gasar Cin Kofin Duniya, Iran ta kara da Masar a Seattle. Marubutan suna cikin filin wasan. A minti na 93, wata ƙwallo ta Shoja Khalilzadeh, wadda ta yi kama da ƙwallon nasara, ta shiga raga, kuma tawagar alƙalan wasa a cikin fili ta yanke hukuncin cewa ba satar gida ba ce (onside). Bayan mintoci na tattaunawa, mataimakin alƙalin wasa na bidiyo (VAR) ya soke hukuncin: bisa ga sake ginin 3D ɗinsa, wani ƙaramin ɓangare na ƙafar mai cin ƙwallon ya kasance a wurin satar gida (offside). Wasan ya ƙare da canjaras. A cewar The Athletic, Iran har yanzu tana da damar 92% ta kaiwa zagayen kawar da ƙungiyoyi (knockout rounds); sakamakon washegari ya kai ta zuwa sifili.
Tambayar marubutan mai sauƙi ce: shin ƙaramar tazarar satar gida da VAR ya bayar ya kamata ta isa ta soke hukuncin alƙalin wasa?
Firam ɗaya yana da tsawon santimita 17
Daidaito a kan allo ba daidaito ba ne a cikin fili. A cikin bidiyon da aka ɗauka a firam 30 a kowace daƙiƙa, ɗan wasan da ke gudu a mita 5 a kowace daƙiƙa yana matsawa kusan santimita 17 tsakanin firam biyu masu bin juna. Ko da ɗan rashin tabbas game da ainihin lokacin da aka buga ƙwallon zai iya fi muhimmanci fiye da milimitocin samfurin 3D.
Amir Ali Ahmadi, na Jami’ar Princeton, da Parsa da Radeen Alavi, na Algonquin Regional High School, sun mayar da wannan rikici zuwa samfurin yiwuwa (probability model). Ainihin tazarar, θ, ita ce nisan ɗan wasan gaba (attacker) fiye da layin satar gida: sama da sifili (positive) yana nufin satar gida. Alƙalin wasa yana ganin ta da kuskure na bazata mai yaɗuwa (spread) σ_H, amma yana faɗin eh ko a’a kawai. VAR yana auna lamba, da nasa kuskuren bazata mai yaɗuwa σ_AI. Ana ɗauka cewa kurakuran biyu na Gauss (Gaussian) ne kuma masu zaman kansu (independent).
Ƙa’idar √(2/π)
Sannan marubutan suka nemi tazarar da ke sa abin da aka gani ya fi yiwuwa — hukunci daga alƙalin wasa da lamba daga VAR — hanyar da ake kira mafi girman yiwuwa (maximum likelihood). Sun tabbatar cewa wannan mafi kyawun ƙiyasi koyaushe yana nan kuma guda ɗaya ne (unique). Abin da ya fi haka, hukuncin ƙarshe ba ya buƙatar wani lissafi ko kaɗan, sai kwatantawa da wata iyaka (threshold):
c = √(2/π) × σ_AI² / σ_H
Idan su biyun ba su yarda da juna ba, VAR yana soke hukuncin alƙalin wasa ne kawai idan tazarar da ya auna ta fi c girma. Ƙasa da haka, hukuncin alƙalin wasa yana nan daram. Lambar √(2/π), kusan 0.80, ta fito ne daga lanƙwasar ƙararrawa (bell curve) kanta.
A ɗauki alƙalin wasa wanda kuskurensa na yau da kullum ya kai santimita 10 da VAR wanda kuskurensa na yau da kullum ya kai santimita 2. Iyakar ita ce santimita 0.32. Tazarar VAR mai saɓani ta santimita 0.20 tana barin hukuncin alƙalin wasa a wurinsa; ta santimita 0.50 tana soke shi. Sanya ɗan wasan gaba fiye da layin bai isa ba: dole ne VAR ya sanya shi a fili fiye da layin.
Kurakurai biyu da ba su da nauyi iri ɗaya
Dabarar lissafin (formula) tana ɗauke da rashin daidaito (asymmetry). Iyakar tana ƙaruwa da murabba’in (square) kuskuren VAR, amma tana bin kishiyar (inversely proportional) na alƙalin wasa ne kawai: idan kuskuren VAR ya ninka biyu, iyakar tana ninkuwa sau huɗu; idan na alƙalin wasa ya ninka biyu, tana raguwa zuwa rabi kawai. VAR mai ƙarin hayaniya (noisier) yana buƙatar shaida mai ƙarfi; alƙalin wasa mai ƙarin hayaniya ya fi sauƙin soke hukuncinsa. Marubutan sun danganta ƙarfi (powers) daban-daban ga nau’o’in bayanai biyu: lamba ga VAR, alama (sign) kawai ga alƙalin wasa.
Haɗa su biyu kuma yana da amfani. Da kurakurai iri ɗaya na santimita 2 da ainihin tazara ta santimita 2, alƙalin wasa shi kaɗai ko VAR shi kaɗai yana yin kuskure 15.87% na lokaci; ƙa’idar haɗaka, 9.70%.
Samfurin yana kuma kula da karkacewa (bias). Alƙalin wasan da ke da karkata ga ɗaga tutar satar gida, da santimita 5 a matsakaici, yana samun iyaka biyu daban-daban: santimita 0.20 don soke hukuncin satar gida, santimita 0.46 don soke hukuncin rashin satar gida (onside). Kuma idan VAR kansa yana da sanannen karkacewa na santimita 1, yin watsi da shi zai iya juya hukuncin.
Don amfani da ƙa’idar, ana buƙatar ma’aunan kuskure (error parameters) guda huɗu. Takardar ta nuna yadda za a ƙiyasta su daga wasannin daidaitawa (calibration plays) inda aka san ainihin tazarar: matsakaici da yaɗuwa masu sauƙi ga VAR, da daidaitawar “probit” (“probit” fit) ga hukuncin eh-ko-a’a na alƙalin wasa.
Bayan filin wasa
Wannan tsari iri ɗaya yana bayyana duk inda ɗan adam ke ba da hukunci kuma na’ura ke ba da ma’aunin adadi iri ɗaya: likita da ke cewa wani rauni (lesion) ba shi da haɗari (benign) ko mai muni ne (malignant) tare da makin AI na ciwon daji mai muni (malignancy score), injiniya da ke amincewa da wani ɓangaren jirgin sama tare da makin tsananin lahani (defect-severity score), manajan asusun zuba jari (fund manager) tare da ribar da wani samfuri ke tsammani (expected return). Marubutan suna ba da shawarar gwada ainihin tasirin ƙa’idar inda daidaitawa (calibration) ke da sauƙi, kamar harkokin kuɗi, ɗaukar hoton likitanci (medical imaging) da kasuwannin hasashe (prediction markets).
An rubuta takardar a matsayin aikin koyarwa, ga ɗaliban jami’a (undergraduates) da ɗaliban sakandare na matakin ci gaba da suka san tushen yiwuwa (probability) da lissafin calculus. Ma’aunanta misalai ne kawai: ba a daidaita (calibrate) wani alƙalin wasa na gaske ko tsarin VAR ba. Layinta na ƙarshe yana cikin godiya (acknowledgements), inda marubutan suka ce sun yi amfani da ChatGPT don hotuna (figures), gyaran rubutu (proofreading) da binciken hankali (sanity checks), “yayin da suke bin ƙa’idarsu ta √(2/π) don tabbatar da cewa AI bai soke hukuncinsu na ɗan adam ba”.
