ICE SEEDS THAT MULTIPLY INSIDE A GLASS
Some liquids can be cooled without ever crystallizing. Their molecules slow down until, at the glass transition, they are frozen in a disordered arrangement: a glass. Yet many of these glasses share an odd habit. Warm them back up through the glass transition and they crystallize readily — a phenomenon called cold crystallization, seen in polymers, small-molecule liquids and water solutions alike. Avoiding crystals on heating is much harder than on cooling.
The usual explanation is that molecules regain their mobility as the glass warms. But the authors of a new study point out a flaw: on the way down, the liquid crossed exactly the same temperatures. Something else must differ between the two journeys — perhaps when the first crystal seeds are born.
What theory expects
A crystal starts from a tiny seed, or nucleus. In the classical theory, two effects compete as a liquid cools. Colder means a stronger drive to crystallize, which lowers the energy barrier to forming a seed. But colder also means slower molecules, which makes forming one harder. The result is a peak in the rate of seed formation, usually found above the glass transition or close to it. Below it, molecules should be too sluggish.
A polymer that holds its water
Mika Kobayashi, Masaru Tanaka and colleagues at Kyushu University, with two researchers from Sumitomo Rubber Industries, chose a biocompatible polymer called PMEA, soaked in water until it held about 10% water by mass. Its glass transition sits at 220 kelvins, and it turns to glass even when cooled very slowly. In a calorimeter, which records the heat released when water freezes, the extra free water freezes around 260 kelvins on cooling; on warming, more of the water crystallizes into ordinary ice around 240 kelvins, before melting around 270.
The key experiment used a microscope. A thin film of the mixture, sandwiched between two glass plates, was cooled at 20 kelvins per minute down to a chosen lowest temperature, held there for less than a second, then warmed straight back, at the same rate, to 226 kelvins — just above the glass transition — and held until the ice crystals stopped growing. Counting the grains reveals how many seeds had formed during the trip.
More seeds in the cold
When the film was cooled only to 213 kelvins — the mildest run, already just below the glass transition — a few large grains grew. Each step colder produced many more, smaller grains. The number of seeds rose steeply once the lowest temperature dropped below the glass transition. From how quickly the count grew, the team derived an effective rate of seed formation. It peaks at about 10 kelvins below the glass transition — where theory says it should already be fading.
The growth stage was the same for every sample, and the growth rate did not depend on how cold the film had been. What mattered was the lowest temperature reached, not the time spent getting there. The seeds formed mostly against the glass plates, which usually pushes the peak upwards in temperature; seeds forming in the liquid alone would peak lower still.
Calorimetry tells the same story. Cooled only to 253 kelvins, the polymer barely crystallizes on warming. Cooled further, a crystallization peak appears, grows and shifts to lower temperatures, then stops changing once the lowest temperature falls below 198 kelvins.
Why glasses crystallize on warming
The authors propose a general scenario. If seed formation peaks below the glass transition, few seeds appear while the liquid is still mobile, so it turns to glass easily. Below the transition, seeds pile up unseen, because molecules are too slow for crystals to grow. On warming, as soon as mobility returns, the waiting seeds grow — crystallization becomes inevitable.
Why this mixture behaves so unusually is still open. The team’s analysis suggests an extra mechanism may be needed, such as a change in how the liquid’s molecules slow down, possibly linked to water, or a sharp drop in the barrier to forming a seed. They suggest that similar hidden peaks below the glass transition may exist in other materials that crystallize on warming, with possible uses in biocompatible polymers, heat-storage materials and polymer processing.
