SHIN BAƘIN RAMIN DA AKA HAIFA YANZU YANA ZAƁAR ENTROPY MAFI GIRMA?
Idan baƙaƙen ramuka biyu suka yi ta kewaya juna har suka faɗa cikin juna, suna barin baƙin rami guda mai juyawa a baya. Kwaikwayon kwamfuta na lissafin Einstein (Einstein’s equations) — numerical relativity — suna hasashen siffofinsa da daidaito mai ban mamaki. Ɗauki baƙaƙen ramuka biyu masu nauyi daidai, ba sa juyawa, a kan hanyar kewayawa (orbit) da ke kusan da’ira: suna barin baƙin rami mai kusan 95.16% na jimillar nauyinsu da juyawa ta kusan 0.69 a kan ma’auni inda 1 shi ne mafi sauri da zai yiwu. Sauran yana tafiya a matsayin raƙuman nauyi (gravitational waves).
Kwaikwayon suna ba da amsar. Abin da ba sa bayarwa shi ne dalili — wata ƙa’ida mai sauƙi ta physics da za ta bayyana dalilin da ya sa ake zaɓar wannan yanayin ƙarshe na musamman.
Doka da aka aro daga thermodynamics
Wata ƙungiyar masana physics ta gabatar da ɗaya kwanan nan, mai suna hasashen entropy mafi girma (maximum-entropy conjecture). Bi diddigin ramukan biyu yayin da suke rasa makamashi da angular momentum (ƙarfin juyawa) zuwa raƙuman nauyi. A kowane mataki, ka yi tunanin wani baƙin rami na hasashe da zai samu nan take da nauyi da angular momentum na ramukan biyu a wannan lokacin. Irin wannan baƙin rami yana da entropy — a physics na baƙaƙen ramuka, adadi ne da ke daidai gwargwado (proportional) da fadin iyakarsa (horizon).
Yayin da ramukan biyu ke ƙara kusantar juna suna kewayawa, entropy na wannan ɗan takara na hasashe da farko yana hawa ya kai ƙololuwa; idan aka ci gaba da lissafin bayan wannan wuri, sai ya sake sauka. Hasashen ya ce ainihin ragowar (remnant) shi ne ɗan takarar da ke ƙololuwa. Wannan gini ne na tunani (construction), ba ainihin entropy na ramukan biyu ba, wanda babu ma’anar da aka yarda da ita a lokacin haɗewa. Duk da haka, da cikakken bayanin matakin kewayawa zuwa juna (inspiral), zuwa mataki na huɗu (fourth order) a cikin ƙiyasin da aka saba (standard approximation), ƙololuwar tana faɗawa cikin ’yan kashi kaɗan na abin da kwaikwayon ke hasashe.
Wannan wata daidaituwa ce mai ban mamaki — ko alamar wata alaƙa mai zurfi tsakanin motsin kewayawa da thermodynamics na baƙaƙen ramuka. Lura (observation) kaɗai ce za ta iya faɗi, kuma Yang Jiang da Qing-Guo Huang, a University of Chinese Academy of Sciences da Institute of Theoretical Physics da ke Beijing, sun tashi don samar da ita.
Sigina ɗaya, an raba ta gida biyu
Sun yi amfani da GW250114, wadda na’urorin ganowa (detectors) biyu na LIGO suka naɗa da sigina mai ƙarfi ba kamar kullum ba: rabon sigina da hayaniya (signal-to-noise ratio) na 78.6. Ta fito ne daga baƙaƙen ramuka biyu masu kusan nauyi ɗaya, da ƙananan juyawa kuma babu tsawaitar hanyar kewayawa da za a iya aunawa — kusa da yanayin kammala da aka gina hasashen dominsa.
Mabuɗin shi ne a raba siginar ta yadda hasashen ba zai taɓa yin tasiri a kan aunawar ba:
- Kafin haɗewar, matakin kewayawa zuwa juna (inspiral) yana bayyana nauyin baƙaƙen ramukan biyu. Daga gare su, ƙungiyar ta lissafa lanƙwan entropy na ’yan takarar kuma ta gano ƙololuwarsa: wannan ita ce tsinkayar (prediction).
- Bayan haɗewar, sabon baƙin ramin yana “ƙara” kamar ƙararrawa da aka buga, cikin raƙuman da ke dusashewa da sauri. Sautinsu (pitch) da saurin da suke mutuwa sun dogara ne ga nauyinsa da juyawarsa kaɗai: wannan ita ce aunawar (measurement).
Tsinkaya da aunawa
Dokar entropy mafi girma tana tsinkayar baƙin rami na ƙarshe mai nauyin rana 70.0 da juyawa ta 0.70. Ƙarar tana ba da nauyin rana 72.3 (ƙari ko ragi kusan 3.6) da juyawa ta 0.74 (+0.05 / −0.07).
Tsinkayar ta fi aunawar kaifi nesa: matakin kewayawa zuwa juna yana ɗauke da zagaye masu yawa, yayin da ƙarar gajeriya ce kuma ba ta da ƙarfi sosai. Juyawar da aka tsinkaya kuma tana da rufi mai tsauri kusa da 0.70 — a cikin wannan nau’in dokar, juyawar ta dogara ne kawai ga yadda nauyin biyun suke daidai, kuma nauyi biyu daidai suna ba da mafi girma.

Nauyi da juyawar baƙin ramin ƙarshe: wanda dokar entropy mafi girma ta tsinkaya daga matakin kewayawa zuwa juna (lemu), da wanda aka auna daga ƙarar (shuɗi). Inuwa mai duhu da mai haske: yankunan amincewa (credible regions) na 68% da 95%. — Hoto na 1, Jiang & Huang (2026), arXiv:2611.05718.
Ƙungiyar ta auna gibin a matsayin karkacewa na dangi (relative deviations). Ga nauyi, −0.03 ± 0.05; ga juyawa, −0.07 (+0.09 / −0.06); ga entropy, tsakiya (median) na −0.03 da kewayon 68% daga kusan −0.09 zuwa 0.04. Sifili — cikakken daidaito — yana cikin kewayon 68%.
Sannan sun sauya inda suka yanke siginar, lokacin da suka fara karanta ƙarar, da kuma ko sun haɗa da sautin ƙara na biyu. Tsinkayar kusan ba ta motsa ba; aunawar ta ɗan sauya, kuma ƙara sautin na biyu ya ɗan tura gibin entropy sama. A kowane hali, sifili ya kasance a cikin kewayon 95%.
Daidaito, ba hujja ba
Marubutan suna taka-tsantsan: sakamakon bai tabbatar da hasashen ba. Ƙarar ce ke iyakance daidaiton, kuma nau’in dokarsu yana ɗauka cewa baƙaƙen ramukan biyu ba sa juyawa, alhali juyawarsu ƙarama ce amma ba a san ko sifili ce daidai ba.
Sigina masu ƙarfi fiye da haka, wani nau’in dokar da ya haɗa da juyawa, da abubuwan da suka faru (events) da yawa a haɗe za su iya warware tambayar: ko entropy mafi girma gajeriyar hanya ce kawai mai ban mamaki zuwa abin da manyan kwamfutoci ke lissafawa, ko ƙa’ida ce da halitta ke bi a zahiri idan baƙaƙen ramuka biyu suka zama ɗaya.
