HUJJAR DA GALOIS BAI TAƁA RUBUTAWA BA
“Wasiƙar wasiyya” (testamentary letter) da Évariste Galois ya rubuta a jajibirin fafatawar (duel) da ta yi sanadin mutuwarsa cike take da lissafi. Sashenta na farko yana taƙaita ka’idarsa (theory) game da lokacin da za a iya warware lissafai na polynomial (polynomial equations), batun wani rubutun nazari (memoir) da ya miƙa wa Kwalejin Kimiyya ta Faransa (French Academy of Sciences) a ranar 16 ga Janairu 1831. Amma kusan kashi ɗaya cikin huɗu na wasiƙar yana magana ne kan wani abu daban: daidaiton siffa (symmetries) na “lissafin modular” (modular equation), wanda ya samo asali daga ka’idar ayyukan elliptic (elliptic functions).
A harshen zamani, waɗannan daidaiton siffa suna samar da wani rukuni (group) da ke jujjuya tsarin abubuwa p + 1 — lambobin 0, 1, …, p − 1 tare da wani wuri da ake kira “rashin iyaka” (infinity) — inda p lambar firamare (prime number) ce. Kowace jujjuyawa juzu’i (fraction) ce x ↦ (ax + b)/(cx + d), da aka lissafa da cikakkun lambobi a modulo p. A cikin wannan rukuni, Galois ya keɓe rabi ɗaya, wanda yanzu ake kira PSL(2, p).
Iƙirari mai keɓancewa uku
Game da wannan rukuni, Galois ya yi iƙirari biyu ba tare da hujja ba. Na farko — cewa ba za a iya farfasa rukunin zuwa ƙananan gutsure ba — ya kira shi mai sauƙi, kuma abin da mai rubuta sabuwar takardar, Péter P. Pálfy na Cibiyar Lissafi ta Alfréd Rényi (Alfréd Rényi Institute of Mathematics) a Budapest, ke amincewa shi ne: “Ba mu da wata masaniya game da irin hujja mai sauƙi da yake tunani a kai.”
Na biyun shi ne wanda Pálfy ke yaba wa Galois a kansa tun koyaushe. PSL(2, p) yana da ƙaramin rukuni (subgroup) mai index p — ƙaramin rukuni da ya fi dukan rukunin ƙanƙanta sau p, wanda zai ba da damar rage lissafin zuwa na digiri p — kawai lokacin da p ya kasance 5, 7 ko 11. Bayan ya ba da misalai ukun, Galois ya rubuta: “A cikakken tsauri (in all rigour), wannan ragewa ba ta yiwuwa a cikin manyan lamurra.”
Wannan “a cikakken tsauri” yana ɓoye wani gyara. A wata gajeriyar sanarwa da aka wallafa a Afrilu 1830, Galois ya yi iƙirarin cewa ragewar ba ta yiwuwa ga kowace p sama da 5. A cikin wasiƙar, ya gyara hakan a hankali kuma ya nace: “duk abin da na rubuta a nan yana cikin kaina kusan shekara guda, kuma ba don amfanina ba ne in yi kuskure har a iya zargina da sanar da ka’idoji (theorems) da ba ni da cikakkiyar hujjarsu ba.” Hujjar kanta, kamar yadda Pálfy ke lura, da alama ba a taɓa rubuta ta ba.
Hujjojin da suka zo daga baya
Hujjar farko da aka wallafa ta fito daga Enrico Betti a 1853, amma ba ta cika ba. Ta farko da ta yi daidai ta bayyana a cikin littafin nazari (treatise) na Camille Jordan na 1870, ta amfani da aljabarar layi (linear algebra); hujjarsa ta gama-gari tana buƙatar p sama da 13, don haka dole ya duba 13 daban. A 1881, jerin dukan ƙananan rukunan PSL(2, p) ya fito daga Joseph Gierster, ɗalibin Felix Klein, kuma iƙirarin Galois ya biyo baya nan take. A yau ana ganinsa a matsayin sakamako mai biyowa (corollary) na wannan rarrabuwa (classification) — wadda aka gina a kan ka’idar rukuni (group theory) da aka haɓaka da daɗewa bayan zamanin Galois.
To, ta yaya Galois zai iya sani? Alamar Pálfy kalma ce. A cikin gutsuttsuran rubuce-rubucen Galois da suka rage, a kan wani yagaggen yanki na takarda da ake ajiye a ɗakin karatu na Kwalejin Faransa, akwai ma’anar da ya rubuta da hannunsa ta rukuni “imprimitive”: rukunin da ke matsar da abubuwansa a cikin tsayayyun tubali (blocks).
Jera abubuwan bi-biyu
Sake ginin da Pálfy ke yi yana amfani ne da wannan ra’ayi kaɗai da ƙirgawa mai sauƙi. Dukan rukunin yana da abubuwa (elements) (p + 1) × p × (p − 1) / 2, don haka ƙaramin rukuni mai index p dole ya kasance da (p + 1)(p − 1)/2. Daga nan, takardar ta nuna cewa irin wannan ƙaramin rukuni dole ne ya jera abubuwa p + 1 zuwa nau’i-nau’i (pairs) da yake riƙe su tare koyaushe — “haruffa masu haɗe” (linked letters) na Galois kansa — kuma ana iya zaɓar alamun ta yadda rashin iyaka zai kasance haɗe da 0.
Kira abokin 1 a cikin nau’i-nau’in da suna M. Lamurra biyu ne suka rage:
- Idan M cikakken murabba’i ne (perfect square) a modulo p, dole ya zama −1, kuma lissafi mai siffar x² + 1 = 0 zai zama gaskiya ga kusan kowace lamba. Yana da mafita (solutions) biyu a mafi yawa, don haka p ≤ 5.
- Idan ba haka ba, kowace lambar murabba’i (square number) banda 0 da 1 dole ta zama mafitar ɗaya daga cikin lissafai na quadratic biyu. Kowannensu yana da mafita biyu a mafi yawa, don haka murabba’ai marasa sifili (non-zero squares) ba za su wuce biyar a mafi yawa ba — abin da ke tilasta p ≤ 11.
Bayan 11, kawai babu yadda za a iya daidaita nau’i-nau’in.
Siffofin Plato (Platonic solids) guda uku
Ga p = 5, 7 da 11, Galois har ya rubuta haɗe-haɗen nau’i-nau’i (pairings) da ke aiki: ga p = 7, misali, ∞ da 0, 1 da 3, 2 da 6, sannan 4 da 5. Takardar ta nuna cewa, idan ba a damu da daidaiton siffa ba (up to symmetry), su kaɗai ne.
Don tabbatar da cewa lalle suna ba da ƙananan rukunoni, Pálfy na bin wata gajeriyar hanya wadda da gangan ba ta zamanin Galois ba ce (anachronistic), domin ga Galois, rukuni koyaushe tarin jujjuyawar (permutations) tushen lissafi (roots) ne. Ƙananan rukunonin uku suna da abubuwa 12, 24 da 60: daidai adadin juyawar (rotations) tetrahedron, kyub (cube) da icosahedron. Sanya wa tsakiyoyin gefuna (edge midpoints) shida na tetrahedron, ko kusurwoyi takwas na kyub, ko kusurwoyi goma sha biyu na icosahedron alamun 0, 1, …, p − 1 da rashin iyaka ta hanyar da ta dace, sai kowace juyawar siffar ta zama ɗaya daga cikin juzu’in (fractions) Galois.

Tetrahedron (p = 5), kyub (p = 7) da icosahedron (p = 11), tare da sanya wa wurarensu alamun 0, 1, …, p − 1 da ∞ ta yadda juyawa ke aiki kamar juzu’in Galois; layuka masu ɗigo-ɗigo: layukan juyawa (rotation axes). — Hoto a Sashe na 4, Pálfy (2026), arXiv:2611.06054.
An sadaukar da takardar don tunawa da Peter M. Neumann, editan rubuce-rubucen lissafi na Galois; Pálfy da Neumann sun yi musayar saƙonnin imel a kan wannan tambaya a 2020. Ko hujjar Galois kansa ta yi kama da wannan, babu wanda zai iya faɗa. Amma tana ba da hujja da aka gina da kayan aikin da yake da su kaɗai — alamar cewa sakamakon yana cikin ikonsa.
