Duniya da yanayiKafin bugawaGwajiKaratun minti 4

FARASHI MAFI INGANCI NA RUWA MAI TSAFTA: SIFILI

Ruwan sha mai aminci har yanzu ya fi ƙarfin yawancin mutanen Bangladesh. A cewar alƙaluman ƙasa da takardar ta ambata, 61% na al’umma — kusan mutane miliyan 100 — ba su da tushen ruwa da ake sarrafawa cikin aminci (safely managed source), miliyan 30 suna amfani da ruwan da arsenic da ke samuwa a halitta ya gurɓata, kuma fiye da huɗu cikin biyar suna shan ruwan da ƙwayoyin cuta (bacteria) suka gurɓata. A yankunan karkara, mafi rinjaye — 92% — suna dogara ne kan rijiyoyin burtsatse na famfon hannu (hand-pumped tubewells).

Ruwan bututu zuwa kowane gida zai warware mafi yawan wannan matsala. Amma dole ne wani ya yanke shawarar nawa gidaje za su biya don a haɗa su, kuma shawarar kamar tana tattare da wani zaɓi mai raɗaɗi. A ƙara farashi, sai kowane gida mai biya ya ɗauki ƙarin ɓangare na kuɗin; amma gidaje kaɗan ne za su haɗa, kuma farashin zai fi ƙarfin mafi talauci. Masana tattalin arziki suna kiran wannan sasantawa tsakanin adalci da inganci (equity-efficiency trade-off).

Bututu na gaske, farashi na gaske

Md. Ahasan Habib, daga NGO Forum for Public Health a Dhaka, da Anna Tompsett, daga Jami’ar Stockholm, sun gwada wannan a cikin al’ummomi biyu na gundumar Bogra, a arewa maso yammacin Bangladesh. Sun gina ainihin tsarin bututu: rijiyar burtsatse mai zurfi da ta kai wani tafkin ruwan ƙarƙashin ƙasa (aquifer) da ke keɓe daga arsenic da ƙwayoyin cuta, famfon lantarki da ke cika hasumiyar ruwa, da bututun da ke kai ruwa ta ƙarfin nauyi (gravity) zuwa famfunan gidaje masu zaman kansu. Yana iya hidimta wa kusan gidaje 200.

Tambayar mutane abin da za su biya ba kasafai take ba da amsoshi na gaskiya ba: wasu suna faɗin ƙasa da haka, da fatan samun ƙaramin farashi, wasu kuma suna faɗin sama da haka, da fatan jawo aikin. Don haka ƙungiyar ta yi amfani da hanyar da ke ba da lada ga gaskiya. Kowane gida ya bayyana mafi yawan abin da zai biya; sannan ya zaro farashi a rufe daga cikin ambulan. Idan farashin da aka zaro ya yi daidai ko ya yi ƙasa da matsakaicin abin da ya bayyana, zai iya haɗawa a wannan farashin — idan al’ummarsa ta ci wata ƙuri’ar jama’a (public lottery) don samun bututun. Faɗin sama da haka yana da haɗarin biyan kuɗi da yawa; faɗin ƙasa da haka yana da haɗarin rasa damar. Wani gwajin farko da sandar sabulu ya tabbatar da cewa gidaje sun fahimci ƙa’idojin.

Buƙatar da ke faɗuwa kamar daga dutse

Gidaje 330 da suka shiga sun zama masu matuƙar damuwa da farashi (very sensitive to price). Lanƙwasar buƙata (demand curve) da aka daidaita tana ba da 88% masu haɗawa a $1, amma 12% kawai a $20; gidan tsakiya (median household) zai biya kusan $6.30. Mai samarwa da ke neman mafi yawan kuɗin shiga zai karɓi kusan $9.70 — kuma kashi ɗaya cikin uku kawai na gidaje ne za su haɗa.

Yanzu ga kuɗaɗen. Tsarin bututun ya ci $4,795 a matsayin tsayayyun kuɗi (fixed costs) — rijiyar burtsatse, famfo da tanki — da kuma kusan $74 a kowane gidan da aka haɗa don bututu da famfuna. Ana raba wannan tsayayyen kuɗi a kan duk wanda ya haɗa, don haka kowane ƙarin gida yana rage matsakaicin kuɗin.

Ta haɗa waɗannan biyun, marubutan suna neman farashin da ke rage kuɗin gwamnati (public cost) a kowane gidan da aka haɗa zuwa mafi ƙaranci. Amsar ita ce sifili. A wannan farashin, kowa da kowa a cikin samfurin (model) yana haɗawa kuma kuɗin ya kai kusan $98 a kowane gida. Duk wani farashi sama da sifili yana korar gidaje da sauri fiye da yadda yake kawo kuɗi: a $9.70, kuɗi a kowane gidan da aka haɗa zai tashi sosai sama da haka. Ko mai samarwa da zai iya karɓar daga kowane gida daidai matsakaicin abin da gidan ke son biya (willingness to pay) zai kai kusan $89 — 9% ƙasa kawai, kafin a ƙidaya kuɗin karɓar kuɗaɗen.

Sakamakon yana da ƙarfi (robust): dole ne niyyar biya (willingness to pay) ta kasance aƙalla ninki 3.4 fiye da wadda aka auna kafin karɓar wani abu ya zama mai amfani.

Abin da gwajin arsenic ya canza

An gina bututun a cikin al’ummar da ta ci ƙuri’ar, inda daga ƙarshe aka sanya iyakar farashi a kusan $8.40. 55% na gidaje sun haɗa, kusa da 53% da aka yi hasashe — kuma dukan gidaje 20 da suka zaro haɗi kyauta sun karɓe shi. Amma amsoshin kowane gida ba su yi hasashen zaɓin kowane gida da kyau ba. Karɓar haɗin ya dogara ne maimakon haka kan sakamakon gwaji, da aka raba bayan binciken (survey): 40% inda ba a gano arsenic ba, 86% inda ya wuce ma’aunin ƙasa. An gwada tushen ruwan shekaru da suka wuce, amma bayanin ya shuɗe: 94% na gidajen da aka gwada tushensu sun yi imanin cewa yana da aminci.

Sharuɗɗa biyu

Wani samfuri (model) mai sauƙi ya nuna lokacin da haɗi kyauta ne zaɓi mafi tattali (cost-effective): manyan tsayayyun kuɗi, da buƙatar da ke da matuƙar damuwa da ko ƙananan farashi — tsarin da marubutan suka lura an rubuta shi sosai a tsakanin gidaje matalauta. Sun yarda cewa wuri ɗaya ne kawai da ƙaramin adadin mahalarta (modest sample), kuma sun bar a buɗe tambayar yadda ya kamata a samar da kuɗin irin waɗannan tsare-tsare. Gargaɗinsu ga masu tsara manufofi a fili yake: inda tattalin girma (economies of scale) ke da ƙarfi, kuɗin haɗi ba sa ƙara faɗaɗa tsayayyen kasafi — suna haɗa gidaje kaɗan ne a kan kuɗi mafi tsada ga kowanne.