OLD ICE IN A YOUNG PLANETARY SYSTEM
Beta Pictoris is a young planetary system, about 20 million years old, 19.6 parsecs from Earth (the parsec is the unit astronomers use for distances to stars). Around its star lies a disk of dust and debris seen exactly edge-on, in which planets are forming; three of them are already known. The disk stretches so far from the star that molecules out there should freeze.
Yet no ice had ever been seen in it directly. Earlier searches found no sign of the water-ice band at 3 micrometres: ice absorbs light at that wavelength, which carves a dip, called a band, into the spectrum — the starlight spread out wavelength by wavelength. The clues were indirect: the disk holds a large supply of carbon monoxide gas, which starlight should destroy within 50 to 300 years. That gas must therefore be replenished, most likely by collisions between comets or small icy bodies.
The disk, seen edge-on
S. K. Betti, of the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore, and colleagues in the United States and Spain observed the disk on 7 December 2023 with the near-infrared spectrograph of the James Webb Space Telescope. Four fields, two on each side of the star, covered a region about 109 by 250 astronomical units (one astronomical unit is the distance from Earth to the Sun), while a reference star helped remove the glare of Beta Pictoris itself.
The team first mapped the depth of the water-ice band: it is roughly the same everywhere in the disk. They then extracted spectra about 100 astronomical units from the star, on both sides. The two are almost identical.
Water and carbon dioxide
The spectra show a broad dip between 2.7 and 3.2 micrometres, the signature of water ice, and narrower dips at 4.25 and 4.39 micrometres, from carbon dioxide ice in its two common forms, one built with ordinary carbon-12 and one with heavier carbon-13. Carbon monoxide shows up only as gas, not as ice.
From the depth of these bands, the team estimates about 3 × 10¹⁷ water molecules per square centimetre along the line of sight, against about 3 × 10¹⁶ for carbon dioxide: a ratio of 1 to 9.3, or about 11% carbon dioxide relative to water. That falls within the range found in the Solar System’s comets (2.5% to 30%) and in disks where planets are just starting to form (7% to 20%).
Ice like glass
Water ice can be crystalline, with molecules lined up in a regular lattice, or amorphous, disordered like glass. Crystalline ice leaves two tell-tale marks in a spectrum: a band at 1.65 micrometres and a sharp peak at 3.1 micrometres. Neither appears here. Models of amorphous ice fit the observed band far better.
At most 4% of the total volume of the grains is crystalline ice — less than 7% of the ice itself. Theory expects mostly crystalline ice in the inner parts of debris disks, warmed by their stars — and the only other debris disk with a water-ice detection, around HD 181327, shows crystalline ice in its inner disk. Farther out, old amorphous ice could remain common. To stay amorphous, ice must remain below about 100 kelvin, or have its crystals broken up by radiation or particles.
A frozen mixture
The carbon dioxide band made with the heavier carbon-13 is shifted and broadened compared with pure carbon dioxide ice. Its shape best matches a laboratory mixture of one part carbon dioxide to ten parts amorphous water, measured between 10 and 50 kelvin. The carbon dioxide is therefore probably not sitting on its own, but intimately mixed into the water ice — consistent with dust temperatures of about 48 kelvin at that distance from the star.
Born between the stars?
If a single large collision had released the ice, it would follow the orbits passing near the crash site, as the carbon monoxide gas does. Instead, the ice is spread evenly, which points to a great many smaller collisions between icy bodies. In the outer disk, these impacts are expected to happen below 2 kilometres per second, too slowly to turn the ice crystalline.
Because the proportions of water and carbon dioxide resemble those of young planet-forming disks and of comets, the authors suggest that, if all these ices share a common origin, they probably formed early, in the cold dense clouds of interstellar space or in the envelope of the newborn star. Locked inside icy bodies, they would have escaped the star’s heat, until collisions ground them into micron-sized grains of “dirty” ice, mixed with other molecules, that JWST can now see.
