A coin toss only looks random. Know every detail of the throw, and you could predict it. Could quantum chance hide the same kind of secret details?
In 1943, a British mathematician said no. His proof used a single photon and a polarizer. It sparked eleven replies, ten of them in the journal Nature, in 1944 and 1945.
A twelfth reply was never printed. A researcher in Geneva found it in Vienna, in Erwin Schrödinger's archives. In a few lines, Schrödinger built exactly the model that was supposed to be impossible.
Yet he was no believer in determinism; he had argued for chance in nature since the 1920s. His model was a proof of principle: an impossibility proof only holds for the problem as it is posed.
Source: Schrödinger's unpublished hidden-variable model in the 1944–45 debate over the "Collapse of Determinism", https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.20752









